Friday, November 15, 2013

The Locker Room Culture of Sports: The Fine Line Between Good Natued Fun and Debilitting Bullying

Hazing has been going on in sports since the beginning of time (a little hyperbole) and harmless initiation to sports team can be seen at various tiers of athletics, particularly at the professional level. Over the years, veteran players have had some very absurd, yet playful and kindhearted demands for the rookies on their team. While the players on the Baltimore Orioles made their rookies wear tutus and dresses, the New York Knicks had their first year players wear pink pajamaswith hearts and teddy bears. Meanwhile, the coaches of the Cleveland Cavaliers made their rookies walk around with strollers and baby dolls for an entire day.

The common thread between all of these amusing gestures was that they were very innocent attempts to have some fun with the new guys on the team. However, the recent bullying incident between fellow Miami Dolphin offensive linemen Richie Incognito and teammate Jonathan Martin has added some real questions to the nature of the hazing that goes on in sports, along with the locker room environment that fosters this type of behavior. While hazing in sports is typically good-natured, the line between a harmless prank and bullying has been blurred following this prominent professional football episode. The appalling harassment that transpired between Incognito and Martin not only demonstrates the extent to which hazing is taken, but it is also elucidates the fact that sports’ locker rooms are much different than a normal working or school environment. 

It is a sad reality that the vicious and merciless aggravation of Jonathan Martin by Richie Incognito could actually occur in a sports setting, where everybody is on one team fighting for the same goal: to win games. The details of the harassment are not an exaggeration or an overreaction by those in the media, or by Martin himself. Among other things, Incognito reportedly extorted at least 15,000 dollars from Martin, left some vulgar and racially charged voice mails and texts on his phone, told Martin he would sexually abuse his sister, and threatened to kill Martin and find the other members of his family and harm them. The locker room culture of professional football, and sports in general, is now under a microscope as a result of the outlandish hazing in the Dolphins locker room. 

The majority of the Miami players noted very conspicuous differences between themselves and Martin. The offensive lineman had come from a very educated family – both of his parents went to Harvard – and he likewise attended a very prestigious academic university, Stanford, after turning down a chance to play at Harvard. A multitude of players on the Dolphins associated Martin’s intelligence, his love of poetry, and his quiet demeanor as a lack of toughness. In fact, there are reports circulating that the Dolphin coaches told Incognito to toughen Martin up because of this perceived weakness. In a locker room atmosphere, Martin’s intelligence ostracized him from the rest of his team in that his play on the field was viewed as “soft.” Richie Incognito, on the other hand, was seen as a tough and vicious player, a guy who had been suspended in college at Nebraska, been arrested for assault, later reinstated to the team, and then suspended again after a fight in a bar. Nonetheless, in the Dolphins locker room, Incognito was seen as the guy everybody wanted to play with, as he was the fierce and vicious competitor, the player who would run through a wall for his teammates. 

This explains why in the aftermath of the allegations of bullying in Miami’s locker room, the players on the Dolphins supported Incognito rather than Martin, despite the verbal epitaphs that were thrown Martin’s way. Offensive tackle Tyson Clabo said, "What's perceived is that Richie is this psychopath racist, and the reality is Richie as a pretty good teammate. I don't know why [Martin is] doing this. And the only person who knows why is Jonathan Martin." Defesnive tackle Randy Starks added, "We're trying to clear Richie's name. He's getting a bad rap." In fact, Martin waited a long time to file a grievance against Incognito because he feared severe repercussions from the other players on the Dolphins.

Many players also supported Incognito because they thought Martin broke an unwritten sports code that “what happens in the locker room, stays in the locker room.” Although Incognito bullied Martin, the fact Martin “squealed” on a teammate was seen as worse than the hazing. Antrel Rolle of the New York Giants said about Martin, “At this level, you’re a man… And take awareness of that, man, you’re a grown-a.. man. You need to stand up for yourself.” Rolle’s comments prove that a professional sport locker room is often defined by toughness and aggressiveness, and despite Martin’s emotional distress, the fact that he needed help to deal with Incognito’s bullying was viewed as a man being vulnerable and weak.

The really intriguing part about the Incognito and Martin bullying incident is that this is not an isolated situation that escalated out of hand, rather, hazing has been happening in college and high school sports for decades. This past fall, the entire Cornell lacrosse team was suspended for hazing as the freshmen on the roster were forced to participate in an alcohol-chugging competition.

Good-natured fun will likely not escalate into the type of abuse that occurred between Richie Incognito and Jonathan Martin.
Many pro athletes share the sentiment that hazing can unite a team if it includes humor without malicious intent. However, the locker room culture of sports is not an inviting atmosphere to those who appear vulnerable, and it just takes one joke that goes too far to create a situation that can get ugly. Sports’ locker rooms can certainly be a place for bullying, which is why coaches and executives in the front office need to be sensitive and aware of even seemingly innocent hazing.

No comments:

Post a Comment